Ana Tsitlidze, who represents the party, said the judge’s assessments at the hearing of 12 November and her reaction to an answer gave an objective observer grounds to suspect a settled negative view of the central issue. Nadaraia quoted the question at issue, “Does the party not share responsibility?”, and said it expressed no opinion.
The plenum’s members were unanimous, he said, in seeing the motion as an attempt to stop a judge asking critical questions. A pointed question does not mean the court has sided with either party, he went on. Nor will a recusal motion be allowed to limit what a judge may ask.
Gotsiridze had pressed both sides. On 11 November, a day before that exchange, she asked Georgian Dream’s representatives whether the provision they cite could make more than 10 parties unconstitutional, against the five their petition names, as CAW reported on 12 November.
The petition of 88 Georgian Dream deputies rests on article 23(3) of the constitution, which rules out parties that aim to overthrow or forcibly change the constitutional order. It names five respondents: the United National Movement, the Coalition for Change, Strong Georgia, the Federalist Party and For Georgia.
Parliament speaker Shalva Papuashvili of Georgian Dream said on the same day that the hearings gave society a chance to pass a political verdict as well as a legal one, and compared the United National Movement’s defence to that of the defendants at Nuremberg.
Interpressnews’s reports of 13 November do not give the party’s answer or the judge’s reaction to it, and they name no date for a ruling.
