Central Asia Wire
Independent Central Asia Monitor
Breaking
Uzbekistan budgets for a $232 billion economy on the day it revises GDP up by 15%Azerbaijan budgets oil at $65 while Azeri Light trades above $100Tokayev rebukes Kazakhstan’s railway two days after its chief was detainedECO foreign ministers meet in Islamabad without Afghanistan at the table
Politics

Georgian judge asks if the ruling party’s test could outlaw more than 10 parties

A judge of Georgia’s Constitutional Court challenged the standard behind Georgian Dream’s petition to have five opposition parties declared unconstitutional at the hearing of 11 November. Eva Gotsiridze asked the petitioners whether the provision they cite could make more than 10 parties unconstitutional. The court’s chairman expelled two opposition representatives during the sitting and later readmitted one.

A fine laboratory sieve heaped with grey gravel, only dust falling through, one amber pebble among the stones.

Gotsiridze told the petitioners that under the provision their petition cites, most political parties in Georgia, more than 10 of them, could turn out to be unconstitutional. She asked whether the standard they proposed was not “too low” and how far it complied with democratic principles, Interpressnews reported.

By her reading, the petition deems five parties unquestionably unconstitutional and mentions another five or more.

Tornike Chieshvili, a Georgian Dream deputy, replied that the petitioners’ approach weighs how high the risk is, how intense the threat and how serious the danger that a particular party poses to the constitutional order.

The petition, signed by 88 Georgian Dream deputies, rests on the first sentence of article 23, paragraph 3, of the constitution, which rules out parties whose aim is to overthrow or forcibly change the constitutional order, infringe the country’s independence or violate its territorial integrity, as CAW reported on 21 October. It names the United National Movement, the Coalition for Change, Strong Georgia, the Federalist Party and Gakharia’s For Georgia, and says the question of other parties may be raised later.

A ban would cancel the parties’ registration. The court, which sits in Batumi, began hearing the case on 21 October and has reached the stage of questioning the parties.

The expulsions came earlier in the sitting. Archil Gorduladze, for the petitioners, said it was common knowledge that Murtaz Zodelava, a former chief prosecutor, was linked to the United National Movement, and Nika Gvaramia, a leader of the Coalition for Change, objected that a university friendship was no party affiliation. After the exchange the chairman, Revaz Nadaraia, expelled Gvaramia under article 32 of the organic law on the Constitutional Court.

He then expelled the coalition’s Maia Kopaleishvili, telling her she lacked the courtesy to listen to him. On the coalition’s motion he later let Gvaramia return and refused Kopaleishvili, whom the coalition’s representative called the principal author of its legal position.

Levan Bezhashvili of the United National Movement told journalists that the petitioners had promised to present concrete evidence before closing statements, and that until now “we have not discussed concrete evidence regarding which party is accused of what”. Gorduladze, who chairs parliament’s legal issues committee, said every question from the bench had been answered in full.

Sittings are scheduled for 12 and 13 November.